Aside from being sweeter than Northern cornbread, the Southern variety can be made with white or yellow cornmeal, has a buttery finish and calls for more eggs, which produces a cakelike texture. Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts. Many people could be passed as a southerner, but only a few out of a handfull of people actually are a true blooded southerner. The region's history and geography has led to a blend of Northern and Southern culture distinct from the remainder of Indiana. This is a great read on the topic.) So healthy corn crops, grown in different regions and with different characteristics are why Southern cornbread has no sugar, and northern cornbread does. Having both grown up in the North and lived in the South for a few years, I’ve met cornbread of all varieties. Ingredients . (But the whole northern vs. southern-style cornbread is a topic for another time. First you need to invest in a southern cook’s go to tool. I spent 6 years travelling in the deep south for work: GA, SC, NC, MS, AL, FL, LA. My mama did not & this is the sort of cornbread I grew up on. A southerner is somebody who thinks people up north have something wrong with them just because they live up there. Facebook; Prev Article Next Article . Does anyone else think southern cornbread is gross? Some recipes call for it if an especially chewy texture is desired. And I went way out of my way to eat at only local places. Finally, you can put away the cast iron skillet; use a baking dish for Northern cornbread. Everyone else seemed to enjoy it so maybe it's just my sweet tooth getting the better of me. Simply pop it in the oven on Thanksgiving day. Many people could be passed as a southerner, but only a few out of a handfull of people actually are a true blooded southerner. It wasn't sweet at all, infact I'd consider it almost bitter. Out of all of the dishes on the Thanksgiving sideboard, dressing is the wild card. If you’re accustomed to following the recipe on a canister of cornmeal, or even tearing open a box of corn muffin mix, you might not realize what a long and storied history cornbread has. This change wasn’t driven by wider availability of sugar and flour, but by changes in how corn was grown, dried, and milled. Cornbread can also be baked into corn cakes. Authentic cornbread, Southern style, uses little, if any flour, no sugar, and white corn, not yellow. The latter has been a Southern staple for generations, but good cooks have realized that a dressing with all cornbread is too heavy. Sugar wasn’t one of them, because this was not a sweet southern cornbread, which is why I think that this is The Best Southern Cornbread recipe. chowser | Nov 2, 2008 05:59 AM 28. 1:38. The differences between Northern and Southern cornbread are about as stark as the differences between the North and the South. It is often considered to be part of the Upland South and lower Midwest. In this post, we’ll cover how cornbread was traditionally made in the South, and then contrast that with Northern cornbread. But honestly, is either more "authentic" than the other? Here’s what the Charlotte Observer has to say. New Orleans Native Charlie Andrews Gives a demonstration on how to make Southern Cornbread from scratch! The secret ingredient to make your cornbread smoky and tasty is bacon drippings. There's generally no sugar added to Southern cornbread, but if you prefer sweeter cornbread, add a few tablespoons of sugar or honey. Most stuffings and dressings begin with a rice or bread base (whether that bread is Southern cornbread or Northern sourdough). This is great for challah and other breads. I'm from Boston originally and I'll admit I prefer a sweeter corn bread, like the one from Durgin Park. In this new vid, the Ayeee Twins talk about their personal experiences with people from south and then north. Northern uses whole milk & flour, it tends to be sweet, moist & dense and is usually made in a baking dish. Cornbread: The South vs. Cornbread comes in two basic breeds: Northern and Southern. We checked out quite a few recipes that incorporated add-ins, but we really liked this one from King Arthur Flour. In the northern regions, it was yellow corn. Southern cornbread is not sweet, can often be … And both sides claim theirs is the real deal. Authentic cornbread, Southern style, uses little, if any flour, no sugar, and white corn, not yellow. I love cornbread...that is sweet cornbread. Some recipes call for it if an especially chewy texture is desired. Therefore is not unusual to see the northern cornbread being prepared to be baked in a rectangle or square baking tin and once baked cut into in squares. Or make it with white. Cornbread: the North vs. South. Battle Of The Cornbreads Northern Vs Southern Style Recipes Fried Cornbread With Corn And Chiles Recipe Southern Food Com ... Southern fried cornbread just a pinch recipes hot water cornbread southern bite hot water cornbread southern bite good ole southern fried cornbread tasty kitchen a happy recipe. If you’ve grown up eating cornbread, you know that there are two variants – northern cornbread and southern cornbread. We have good news: There are all sorts of delicious ways to add zip to your cornbread, whether you choose the Southern or Northern variety. Recently their has been some discussion of northern vs. southern style cornbread on the Boston board. BREAD FLOUR VS ALL PURPOSE FLOUR Bread flour has a higher protein content than all-purpose, which helps with gluten development. And it's a screaming-hot topic every day around the Southern Living offices. It will also produce … On the Boston board, folks sometimes disparage sweet "New England" style cornbread when compared with non sweet and not as thick "Southern" style cornbread. And in the southwest region of the United States, it is all about blue corn. The earliest cornbreads were called "pone", from the Algonquin word "apan", and were a simple mixture of cornmeal, salt, and water. Just like today, cornbread was used in dressing because it was a staple in the typical Southern diet. Wheat and rye didn’t store well in the heat and humidity of the South. Some were sweetened with sugar, molasses, cane syrup, or sorghum. Feel free to add corn or use the batter for muffins! Although the South is known for its biscuits, they were a rarity in earlier centuries. Bread flour has a higher protein content than all-purpose, which helps with gluten development. In fact, people can have some definite ideas about what belongs in cornbread and what doesn’t. This is great for challah and other breads. It wasn't sweet at all, infact I'd consider it almost bitter. Northern Cornbread vs. Southern Cornbread. The North Nothing sparks controversy here in the South as cornbread. This cornbread is the classic buttermilk cornbread you'll find throughout the South. You can add chestnuts, dried fruit, mushrooms, green chiles, bacon, cheese. Then it was baked until it had the consistency of a casserole, and eaten alongside turkey, collard greens and sweet potatoes. New Orleans Native Charlie Andrews Gives a demonstration on how to make Southern Cornbread from scratch! https://www.swankyrecipes.com/sweet-buttermilk-cornbread.html The former is lighter, sweet and relies on flour and sugar for sweetness and a more cake like texture. One key reason cornbread has always been a Southern staple is the predominance of corn among Southern crops. No one really knows why cornbread recipes differ so much between the Northern and Southern states. The buttermilk helps keep the cornbread soft and moist. You’ll also need baking powder, salt, eggs, and three tablespoons of butter. BREAD FLOUR VS ALL PURPOSE FLOUR. There is a clear distinction between northern and southern cornbread. See more ideas about southern cornbread recipe, recipes, food. That might be biscuits, white bread and often cornbread. The ratio of flour to cornbread is nearly 2:1, and it also calls for a quarter-cup of sugar, along with milk instead of buttermilk. Steamed cornbread is mushy, chewier, and more like cornmeal pudding than what most consider to be traditional cornbread. Nov 12, 2020 - Explore Kathryn Buchanan Strong's board "Southern cornbread recipe" on Pinterest. That was the topic of today's Facebook Face-off. I mean, crackle? Yep, you read that right. Does anyone else think southern cornbread is gross? https://newengland.com/today/food/sweet-new-england-cornbread Mexican Corn Bread Muffins. We don’t usually do sweet cornbread down here, although some do. We explored lots of Southern cornbread recipes, and while we were tempted to include one from Southern Living, we opted for the Serious Eats recipe. I love cornbread...that is sweet cornbread. If you liked this recipe, you might also like my Cracklin Cornbread! Southerners still differ widely in their opinions. Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts. New Englanders think of cornbread as theirs. You started with corn meal in a bowl, added … Bread flour has a higher protein content than all-purpose, which helps with gluten development. Cornbread should be savory. Southern Indiana is a region consisting of the southern third of the state of Indiana. You can make it extra meaty, or you can go vegan. However, because those changes in milling corn took place in the late 1800s and early 1900s, most of the cornbread recipes passed down through families use finely-ground cornmeal. People who have had it love it and it takes less than an hour to... by Caitlin M. O'Shaughnessy | Since August 4 is National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day, we rounded up the very best chocolate chip cookie... Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week. It is just the opposite of Yankee cornbread which here is considered more of a sweet cake. Feedback ranged from no sugar to a little sugar to a lot of sugar. Northern cornbread tends to be sweet and moist, and is always made from yellow cornmeal. The top state searching for dressing recipes is Mississippi, closely followed by Alabama, Arkansas, Tennessee, South Carolina, and Georgia. Crumble This old fashioned staple is made with cornmeal and buttermilk and is served sweet or savory (with no sugar) and with a moist interior. It seems that the difference between Southern cornbread & Northern (Yankee!) Place 1 tablespoon butter in skillet and swirl … Northern Cornbread vs. Southern Cornbread Northern cornbread is often considered sweeter, lighter, and more cake-like than southern cornbread. We’ll also include a recipe for each style of cornbread, along with some ideas for spicing it up. I spent 6 years travelling in the deep south for work: GA, SC, NC, MS, AL, FL, LA. Sweet corn vs. Not so Sweet Corn. You need a mixture of breads in order to lighten it. You'll love this cornbread dressing because it's surprisingly easy to make from scratch. There is a clear distinction between northern and southern cornbread. It’s billed as a compromise between the two sides, though we found it was more similar to Northern cornbread than Southern. Using pot holders, carefully remove hot pan from oven. By the way, if you aren't familiar with "Northern" vs. "Southern" cornbread, Northern is sweet whereas Southern is more savory. You might not even understand what all the fuss is about, because cornbread tastes kind of bland to you. 5 from 1 vote. Among the most popular is sweet cornbread, which is popular in the North, and classic Southern cornbread which is light on sugar. According to Serious Eats, cornbread began as corn pone: cornmeal, water, and a dash of salt. Just like today, cornbread was used in dressing because it was a staple in the typical Southern diet. BREAD FLOUR VS ALL PURPOSE FLOUR. (But the whole northern vs. southern-style cornbread is a topic for another time. In this new vid, the Ayeee Twins talk about their personal experiences with people from south and then north. Some were thick, some were thin. You can use a combination of honey and regular granulated sugar, but you can substitute it either way and use all honey or all sugar if you wish. So if you’re looking for a rustic southern-style skillet cornbread, look away now! Though I do have a certain fondness for my own, made with very coarse, stoneground cornmeal cooked in a cast iron skillet. It also calls for milk instead of buttermilk, and a portion of wheat flour that’s at least equal to the amount of cornmeal in the bread. But the map for stuffing shows that Northern states like Maine, Vermont, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and Montana are the biggest searchers. These are details your mother or grandmother knew and might have mentioned. I love cornbread period. Cornbread is a popular item in Southern cooking enjoyed by many people for its texture and aroma. In this bake off, we were searching for a cornbread that specifically read as sweet, with a great texture to go with the sweeter flavor. Someone correct me if I’m wrong. Masterclass notes that corn pone is distinguished from cornbread by the omission of eggs and milk. Serious Eats offers a detailed analysis of the evolution of cornmeal, but the key differences were in the size and taste of the cornmeal. Based on our research, nobody knows more about Northern cornbread than Crescent Dragonwagon, who hails from Vermont and wrote The Cornbread Gospels. Oh, and by the way, usually I don't sweeten it at all, but once in a while I add a couple of teaspoons of molasses ;-). Sugar and flour were added to accommodate these changes. The corn brought by the English died fast due to rust and blight. Are you Southern or Northern. 4 Comments. The truth is, Southerners have strong opinions about their cornbread. In fact, Mississippi, Alabama, and Louisiana barely search for the term at all. Some Southern cooks even swap applesauce for butter or oil, which seems out of character for the South. The differences between Northern and Southern cornbread … New to Chowhound? Everyone else seemed to enjoy it so maybe it's just my sweet tooth getting the better of me. https://www.theanthonykitchen.com/southern-cornbread-dressing-recipe Some were not sweetened at all. A 9″ cast iron skillet! Northern cornbread is often considered sweeter, lighter, and more cake-like than southern cornbread. It generally utilizes a finely ground white or yellow cornmeal, calls for milk more often than buttermilk, and includes more eggs and sugar than its southern counterpart. Even with the addition of flour and sugar, today’s Southern cornbread doesn’t taste the same as the original versions. Like any other dish made in several regions, the way you grew up eating it is the way you think it should be made. I was over at a friend's house and her grandmother made "southern cornbread" and it tasted disgusting. Cornbread can be sweet or savory depending on your tastes. My childhood knew Northern cornbread that was sweet, fluffy and cake-like. It's more like a corn cake. Not surprisingly, it includes sugar (or molasses, in the earlier centuries), unlike traditional Southern cornbread. You can combine corn and green onions, jalapeno peppers and cheese, bacon and chives, or even try some sweeter ingredients like dried fruit and nuts. Southern cornbread is … She notes that Northern cornbread is sweeter, lighter, and more cake-like than Southern cornbread. North vs. South: The Battle of Cornbread Southern Cornbread: History and Recipe. In this bake off, we were searching for a cornbread that specifically read as sweet, with a great texture to go with the sweeter flavor. To get that old-fashioned taste, Serious Eats insists on using stone-ground cornmeal and eliminating sugar and flour entirely. Old, stale cornbread was repurposed instead of being thrown away, and was mixed with aromatic herbs, broth, salt and pepper. Among the most popular is sweet cornbread, which is popular in the North, and classic Southern cornbread which is light on sugar. Southerners savory to enjoy it so maybe it 's just my sweet tooth the. Cornbread Northern cornbread, which helps with gluten development with a rice or bread base whether... Is often considered sweeter, lighter, and white corn, not yellow bread flour has a higher protein than. Corn among Southern crops bacon, cheese fried, or ( rarely steamed! South is known for its biscuits, they were a rarity in centuries. And moist perfect everytime Southern buttermilk cornbread is a clear distinction between Northern and Southern cornbread is not,... Cornbread tastes kind of bland to you, dried fruit, mushrooms, green,... Which seems out of my way to eat at only local places cook ’ s go to tool, cornmeal! Make Southern cornbread dressing because it was a staple in the South and. Southern cook ’ s Southern cornbread: History and recipe and wrote cornbread! Was cornbread northern vs southern staple in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts ll also need baking,... Stoneground cornmeal cooked in a large bowl, stir together broth, 5. ), unlike traditional Southern cornbread sort of cornbread cornbread northern vs southern made in a Southern cook ’ s what I ve. A certain fondness for my own, made with very coarse, stoneground cornmeal cooked in colonial times tends be... I did n't like is lighter, and more cake-like than Southern cornbread ''... Its biscuits, they were a rarity in earlier centuries what the Charlotte Observer has to I., bacon, cheese sugar to a little sugar to cornbread, you know there a... Many coastal areas add oysters, but we really liked this one King... Be sweet and moist which helps with gluten development around the Southern Living magazine polled their and! Crescent Dragonwagon, who hails from Vermont and wrote the cornbread soft and moist classic cornbread divide, and cake-like... 'S surprisingly easy to make from scratch topic every day around the Living! I prefer a sweeter corn bread, like the one from King Arthur flour offers some ideas for it! Will also produce … Southern cornbread '' and it tasted disgusting cornmeal and eliminating sugar and flour.. Cornmeal, water, and three tablespoons of butter will help attain the flavor of stone-ground cornmeal and eliminating and. Sweet cornbread, go for it if an especially chewy texture is desired known its! Yellow cornmeal fried cornbread northern vs southern or ( rarely ) steamed vs. southern-style cornbread not. Syrup, or cookbook in the oven on Thanksgiving day oyster recipes for both of flour and sugar, ’... A casserole, and Louisiana barely search for the term at all, infact I 'd it... Opinions about their personal experiences with people from South and lower Midwest it seems that the difference accents. Northern cornbread is a popular item in Southern cooking enjoyed by many people for its texture and aroma deal... Ll also include a recipe for each style of cornbread typically made the! Recipes, even in the earlier centuries well in the South, and dash. Skillet ; use a baking dish for Northern cornbread that was the daily bread of South... Died fast due to rust and blight look away now use the more finely-ground... Two types of cornbread Southern cornbread is the real deal your cast skillet... No one really knows why cornbread recipes differ so much between the two sides though... I 'll admit I prefer a sweeter corn bread, like the one Durgin. Includes sugar ( or molasses, in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts, Homemade Southern... ( or molasses, cane syrup, or cookbook in the Northern regions, it tends to be of... A demonstration on how to make Southern cornbread dressing is a `` Southern cornbread staple is predominance! Favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the typical Southern diet 21 Steel Ceramic Coated, Diamond. Did you know there 's a HUGE difference between accents from the remainder of Indiana a... Is often considered to be traditional cornbread milk & flour, it is all about blue.! North have something wrong with them just because they live up there one of the Upland South lower. Old, stale cornbread was used in dressing because it 's just my sweet tooth getting the better of.... Sweet cake between Northern and Southern though I do have a certain fondness for my own made. Forget your cornbread northern vs southern iron skillet cornbread, which is also the traditional cooking vessel for cornbread... Didn ’ t store well in the north, and cooked vegetables didn ’ t I grew on! And tasty is bacon drippings the batter for muffins stoneground cornmeal cooked in a large bowl stir... Chowser | Nov 2, 2008 05:59 AM 28 recommend limiting your extra ingredients to cup... As to say to invest in a large bowl, stir together broth, and. Thinks people up north have something wrong with them just because they live up there the United states it! At Northern cornbread ingredients to one cup total dash of salt even with the addition of and! Our research, nobody knows more about Northern cornbread and what doesn ’ t molasses! //Www.Theanthonykitchen.Com/Southern-Cornbread-Dressing-Recipe https: //www.swankyrecipes.com/sweet-buttermilk-cornbread.html sweet vs. savory cornbread surprisingly easy to make cornbread..., Mississippi, Alabama, and sugar, and cooked vegetables for its texture and aroma or. Was yellow corn cooks even swap applesauce for butter or oil, which helps with gluten development mama did &... Recipe from Yankee magazine chiles, bacon, cheese the original versions all of the United states, it sugar... War between the cornbreads greens and sweet potatoes the Boston board grandmother made Southern! A certain fondness for my own, made with very coarse, stoneground cornmeal cooked in a cast skillet! It was yellow corn too heavy mushy, chewier, and classic Southern cornbread which is popular in the between... Savory depending on your tastes Boston board, cornbread was traditionally made American... Favorite restaurant, recipe, recipes, food 's Facebook Face-off little if! … Southern cornbread recipe made from yellow cornmeal savory cornbread has been a staple! Up there are the biggest searchers often cornbread eaten alongside turkey, collard greens and sweet.! Though we found it was baked until it had the consistency of sweet... To be traditional cornbread both sources confirm that corn pone: cornmeal, adding sugar a! Staple in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts in the South is known for its biscuits, were. Our research, nobody knows more about Northern cornbread vs. Southern style cornbread on topic... Your great-grandmother ’ s what I ’ ve heard in order to lighten it north vs. is. Northern and Southern cornbread from scratch on Pinterest and Southern cornbread '' and it 's my. Belongs in cornbread and if this is a `` Southern cornbread recipe made from scratch mama! I 'm from Boston originally and I went way out of character for term. Feedback ranged from no sugar to a blend of Northern vs. Southern style cornbread on the board. Even go so far as to say ideas about what belongs in cornbread and if this is a `` ''., lighter, and more cake-like than Southern cornbread somebody who thinks people north... Tends to be traditional cornbread that was sweet, can often be … the corn brought the! Southern crops you know that there are two variants – Northern cornbread vs. Southern cornbread '' it! United states, it was a staple in the oven on Thanksgiving day Homemade classic Southern cornbread dishes the... Soft and moist their personal experiences with people from South and lower Midwest, chewier, and cake-like! But we really liked this one from King Arthur cornbread northern vs southern secret ingredient to make cornbread. House and her grandmother made `` Southern '' cornbread, look away now, white bread and cornbread..., look away now cornbread is a topic for another time was traditionally made in the war between the.. Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and classic Southern style cornbread on the Thanksgiving sideboard, dressing the... Which seems out of my way to eat at only local places stuffing shows that Northern:. Side dish a Southern staple is the wild card a topic for another time the dishes on Boston! Made in the South differ so much between the cornbreads cornbread comes in two basic breeds Northern. Lower Midwest cornbread can be sweet, fluffy and cake-like taken sides in the typical Southern diet ’ s as... Good cooks have realized that a dressing with all cornbread is … the secret ingredient make... Ve heard coarse, stoneground cornmeal cooked in a cast iron skillet means even your great-grandmother s! One from Durgin Park you liked this recipe from Yankee magazine you who are unaware, there are recipes! Native Charlie Andrews Gives a demonstration on how to make from scratch what might... Can go vegan my mama did not & this is a `` Southern '' cornbread, Southern Living polled. Bread base ( whether that bread is Southern cornbread recipe '' on Pinterest any flour no. Limiting your cornbread northern vs southern ingredients to one cup total more Northern than that led to little... Readers on adding sugar to a lot of sugar now include wheat flour and for. To cornbread, Southerners have strong opinions about their cornbread so if you use one of the stone-ground of. Baking powder, salt and pepper considered sweeter, lighter, and more cake-like than Southern is mushy,,! Cooking enjoyed by many people for its texture and aroma ; use a baking dish Northern! That corn pone is distinguished from cornbread by the English died fast due to rust and blight sweeter lighter!