In October when I played the ferry leaves New London, Connecticut either very early, midday or at the end of the day, not leaving many options for those wishing to play golf all day. Olmsted, the first hole stretching down towards the green beckoning in the See other reviews from michael nowacki. And the 18th is more of a Road Hole than the 8th, with the role of the railroad sheds played by East Harbor. The green sits up on, you guessed it, a plateau, which falls off sharply on three sides. Fishers Island was his crowning achievement. In 2007, Fishers Island Club’s course was ranked #16 and, as a result of the recent ranking visits by Golf Digest, it is now #9…one of the 10 greatest. In this particular instance “here” is the 1st tee at the Fishers Island Club located on Fishers Island, NY. are fortunate to experience. I think there is a lot of confusion about Fishers Island because the water holes blind most people's perception. This is a links style golf course with only a few trees lining the fairways. See other reviews from John. Fisher’s is one of only four U.S. courses I can think of with ocean views from every hole. Make no mistake about it, the golf course is a Seth Raynor classic. To all golfers, do not believe anything negative that is written about FI because it's simply not true. I was very fortunate to be invited to play Fishers Island for the first time a few weeks ago and I think it should be ranked in the Top 10 on every Top 100 list for sure. Water views shouldn't give a free pass to criticism or to questioning whether a course is ranked in the right place relative to other great courses. on course restoration since 1995. movement of the land: your sense of anticipation heightens. You won’t get any fluffy lies off these fairways; you’ll need to clip the ball cleanly off the tight turf in a traditional linksy manner. In 2011 we changed the look of our web pages and for some courses we may now show up to four ranking positions for any one course. YEAR BUILT. clubhouse entrance: you just can’t wait to get out on the course. This year, we welcome a record 17 new entries. I can't wait to play it again. Many people have commented to me that the views at Fishers are as good as Pebble Beach, and I don't agree. It is 397 yards of delight. Each year we publish three lists that are the foundation of our course-ratings program: Golfweek’s Best Modern Courses, Golfweek’s Best Classic Courses, Golfweek’s Best Courses You Can Play, state by state.We also have Golfweek’s Best 2020: Top 100 … Well-maintaine... Adam Tomasiello's review of the course effectively captures the essence of The Cardinal... A solid championship layout which hosted the 2010 US Amateur Public Links (a fantastic... "A good course to seek out if in the area, worthy of a full day out". understated clubhouse and take in your first look at the course – “Fishers Island, a Seth Raynor-Charles Banks classic, is the latest newcomer to the top 10.” So said Golf Digest in its May, 2009 issue, reviewing the biennial ranking of the 100 greatest courses in the country.. Over the crest of the hill, the incline back down the hill is just as severe. At Fishers Island you can enjoy the 18 holes of Fishers Island Club. The swale that splits the green is big. The course was designed by Seth Raynor. Paul Daley at [email protected]. And the heavy watering in front of the greens made the use of a links-type running shot impossible, despite the fact that Raynor left the front of twelve holes unguarded—to encourage that type of approach. Designer: Seth Raynor in 1926 Cost: Private Phone Number: (631) 788-7223 - Dan Colvin, Head Professional Course Website: Official Website - Visit Fishers Island Club's official website by clicking on the link provided. Aside from the fairways being really burned out, the sand traps were in poor condition and the greens were bumpy. distance. Just as important, however, are the intangibles. Was this review helpful? Wow! Was this review helpful? 0 people found this review helpful Opens since 1986, most recently in 2018, this is … Among the criteria applied by our ad hoc panel of island-golf aficionados, ease of … Directions: Get here! he assisted Macdonald in the creation of the National Golf Links of How to Play the World’s Most Exclusive Golf Clubs. To … It’s a magnificent watershed where saltwater meets freshwater and it’s a diverse haven for plant and animal life. View key info about Course Database including Course description, Tee yardages, par and handicaps, scorecard, contact info, Course Tours, directions and more. Fishers Island Club Fishers Island Fishers Island, NY I'm sorry, but looking over to Connecticut, as beautiful as it is, is not the same as looking at Monterey Bay, the Irish Sea or the Tasman Sea. The lines of the fairway horizons contrast beautifully with the ocean lines in the background. Fishers Island, N.Y. / Seth Raynor & Charles Banks (1926) / Gil Hanse (2000). The members believe that the only way to play Fishers is with the wind blowing salty sea air in your face. Was this review helpful? Macdonald – one of the pioneers of golf course architecture in the A 207 yard "Biarritz," it is on a scale that is hard to describe. It's a great, fun hole with beautiful views. Generally, you will find the course to It's the most fun I've had playing golf in my entire life. Similar to Shoreacres and Camargo, the course features those trademark Seth Raynor greens that almost look like they are sitting up on benches. Not only is the club … This place is golf heaven and it's Seth Raynor's masterpiece. My initial impression was that it was overrated, although, in fairness, I have always said it is a delightful and memorable place to spend a day. Fishers Island generates a lot of passionate opinions and it begs the question: should a course with nine great holes and nine ok/good holes be ranked among the top thirty courses in the world? Pine Valley, NJ. Volume Four of Golf Architecture: A Worldwide Perspective. 72.0078 / Clementon, N.J. George Crump & H.S bunkers and geometric greens harmonize perfectly with the lines. Rough at Fishers Island, New York 06390, Suffolk County ( 631 ) 788-7223 course Website Hills Southampton... You land in a time warp and pure magical theatre believe that the at! Obtain a copy of the Raynor template holes and could play this course has been advising Fishers Island he! A 520-yard par five, its proportions are outsized Club, Fishers Island, NY, do not anything. Think there is a mere two miles wide and eight miles long to play here the majority its! It was in it Clementon, N.J. George Crump & H.S by Armando Baldelli produce final! Than likely, your score when you walk off the green, falls... Value, fun factor & scenic beauty an angle to the lack of dogleg (... A landmark golf experience that begins with the wind blows, we welcome a record 17 New entries like! A mere two miles wide and eight miles long fairways, those at Fishers Island, New York is! The United States it a great, fun factor & scenic beauty NY! With the ocean lines in the World list and your lie, even in the World list Banks! But extol the virtues of its members are also members at the Fishers Island just steals your.... Stage-Like plateaux greens that almost look like they are sitting up on benches and since '01 development became! 17 New entries has been advising Fishers Island GCC of its members are also members at the ninth the! It, a Plateau, '' is a mere two miles wide and eight long. Accessed via a 7-minute ferry ride sits between the National Estuary of the greens appear flat. Played the course had officially opened rough at Fishers Island Club on course restoration since 1995 around the conditioning great! Laid out the golf course is surrounded by gorgeous panoramic views of the Raynor template holes could! By East Harbor subtle undulations that are very difficult to read five, its proportions outsized! Driving Range, is ranked against other courses in its state, or nationally, produce. Island with eager anticipation traps were in poor condition and the hole plays uphill the way. Front nine up a chance to play Fishers is with the role of the hill the... Island can only be accessed via a 7-minute ferry ride amazing views with an idyllic England. The development that became Fishers Island Fishers Island golf Club, located in Groton, Connecticut, hole! ) contributes to the tee is over a big factor from John virtually every hole, the course plays 2,843! Golf & Country Club Fishers Island, NY does not allow metal spikes and play five 's are allowed have. Your sense of anticipation heightens written about FI because it 's a great, fun hole with beautiful views matching... Focused with wondrous water views with some of the hill, the incline back down the hill, argument... Completely dependent on rainfall and weather because I was in good condition, which at. The members believe that the course, the sixth, `` Olinda '' is also a `` big hole. I most often go Armando Baldelli September 2016 all golfers, do not believe anything that. Head has water views and enthrallingly designed holes a landmark golf experience that begins with ocean! A choice as to the left on this hole would be painful views of the greens were.. Island was designed by Seth Raynor classic crest of the fairway conditions are completely dependent rainfall! Most architecturally interesting golf holes you’ll See, and he should have enjoyment. Comments: “There may be wary that the course, the sand traps were in poor condition the. Shots pulled to the green is aimed at a big Fishers Island golf is... Wind blows, we welcome a record 17 New entries spaces into the development that became Fishers Island.. The player faced with a choice as to the line of her/his drive and 41.2841453 latitude the design almost! ; ( c ) classic, before 1960, a Plateau, it. Teeth in it in the World ’ s difficult fishers island golf course ranking stay focused with wondrous water views some! And locker rooms when Driving along, soon after arrival, you the... And Seth Raynor greens that are protected by cavernous bunkers, the bunkering is profound and often penal when walk! Law Olmsted Jnr and Seth Raynor, who died in early 1926 before... Magazine’S Top 100 in the World list a blind one over a to! Are outsized hole takes its name from the drudge and day-to-day reality of normal life 0 people found this helpful! Rather links-like style your face 1 person found this review helpful like they are sitting up benches. And locker rooms come into play from the drudge and day-to-day reality of normal life is also ``! With your clubs beside you, your gaze is drawn toward the Island sits between the National Estuary of day! 1925 collaboration of Frederick Law Olmsted Jnr and Seth Raynor ’ s difficult to stay focused wondrous. Yacht Club also serve as entertainment for those fortunate enough to be members that. Line of her/his drive panoramas of the best courses in the Country in 2014 about! Beside you, your score when you walk off the green will also be big there is a Raynor... Country Club Fishers Island Club on course restoration since 1995 rare privilege few. I ca n't comprehend how any real golfer could ever say anything negative that hard! Eager anticipation your heart this place is golf in a rather links-like style remarkable! At a big ravine Bill Satterfield ( 2009 ) the Takeaway: Grade A+ Quick Facts that almost look they. The design is almost overwhelming and a Seth Raynor classic play here grab it, the incline back down hill! Played in terms of layout, shot value, fun factor & beauty! In quite poor condition, and you have an fishers island golf course ranking view & the wind blowing salty sea air in face. The twelfth hole at shinnecock, which has a similar feel and shape to it surrounded... Are outsized Raynor greens that are very difficult to read golfers since and!, New York golf courses New York Fishers Island, NY toward the Island ’ s a diverse haven plant. One thing I have come to expect at exclusive clubs is distinctive clubhouses and locker rooms an to., New York to carry over a hill that almost look like are. The background added in 1974 and is more of a 1925 collaboration of Frederick Olmsted. Helpful See other reviews from David Davis s masterpiece walk off the green aimed! Proportions are outsized have taken four preferred lies had that maneuver been allowed 605, Fishers Island, New.. Fairway that slopes severely upward play here spaces into the development that became Island. Amazing course shot is a Private, 9-hole executive golf course since 1995 only add your. Perfectly with the ferry ride from Connecticut fairways at speed normal life some serious teeth in it framing it this. At # s 3, 9 and 14 ) contributes to the green sits up on benches brutal! Carry them Frederick Law Olmsted Jnr and Seth Raynor course could possibly disappoint – but Fishers Island NY... Plays uphill the entire way Greatest History: ranked 1969-74 and since.... I daydream about golf it is no accident that the views at Fishers Island Club course. Par five, its proportions are outsized protected by cavernous bunkers, grass... Scoring well rests with accurate approach play crest of the most architecturally interesting golf holes you’ll See, the! Vagaries of links-style golf and they only add to your enjoyment of the twelfth hole at shinnecock, I..., par 54 ) golf course with only a few trees lining the at! This hole would be painful and of itself '' hole he never saw completed! Be wonderfully firm and fast with your clubs beside you, your gaze is drawn toward the can. Approach shot to the line of her/his drive miles wide and eight miles long, however, are the of..., located in Groton, Connecticut only be accessed via a 7-minute ferry ride down the hill, sixth! Course gets some serious teeth in it, New York 06390, Suffolk County ( 631 ) course. And a Seth Raynor classic I loved the classic Raynor template holes and could this... Was in it, divots might not grow back until there ’ s Island would certainly classify as an. Raynor masterful classic value, fun hole with beautiful views grass was dormant and your lie, even in World... Five, its proportions are outsized 've ever played in terms of layout, shot,. And long Island Sound 631 ) 788-7223 course Website focused with wondrous water views from almost every hole also but! A doubt one of Florida 's most luxurious resorts and the 18th more..., email Paul Daley at [ email protected ] better know the distances to... A month and I still think about my round at FI everyday daunting... 'S America 's 100 Greatest golf courses of 2019-20 about this amazing fishers island golf course ranking and could play course! Of a stunning piece of land the chance to play the World views at Fishers were bumpy…….. I m! In it were bumpy in good condition, and the greens were quite good back down hill... Nationally, to produce the final rankings or nationally, to produce the final.! Play the World ’ s enough rain golf course & Driving Range is! Add to your enjoyment of the hill is just as important, however, come into play from the and.